In March we recapped the REITs Q4 earnings season, highlighting a regional focus seemed the best way to position among the apartment REITs to mitigate immigration headwinds.

The trade has played out to some degree, with Boardwalk (BEI-U, Alberta exposure) and Killam (KMP-U, Atlantic exposure) faring better than names with heavy Ontario exposure like Minto (MI-U) and CAPREIT (CAR-U).

Fundamentally we’ve started to see some divergence as well, as Q1 results show better same-property NOI growth at Boardwalk and Killam…

… higher rent growth…

… and more favourable occupancy trends.

Oil prices change our view on the trade

In isolation, the underlying regional thesis still holds, but a less energy friendly government and a 15% drop in crude oil prices since April introduces a new wrinkle to the trade. Given Boardwalk’s Alberta exposure, oil prices tend to drive share price.

They also drive fundamentals over a longer period, with both rents and occupancy grinding lower for multiple years after the 2015 oil slump.

At a time where new housing supply is picking up…

… and provincial unemployment remains elevated…

… we’d reduce exposure to Boardwalk until a recovery in oil prices takes place.

About Bullpen: Bullpen Finance Inc. publishes content on Canadian markets and provides paid research coverage of select Canadian issuers. Bullpen is paid in cash by covered issuers, does not accept stock or options, does not hold positions in covered securities, and does not conduct investment banking business. Bullpen and LodeRock Advisors Inc. are affiliated; LodeRock provides investor relations services to issuers, some of whom are covered by Bullpen Research. When a post discusses a covered issuer, a specific disclosure appears at the top of the post. This post is published for general information purposes. It is not personalized investment advice and is not tailored to any individual reader’s circumstances. Bullpen is not a registered investment adviser or dealer. For full disclosures, including analyst certification, jurisdictional statements, and conflict of interest policies, please see our Legal & Disclosures section on our website.

You might be interested in…